Which would be better for hay?

Hector gets on really well with having his hay in his treat ball, but I really want something bigger (but not massive) so which do you think would be better?

1. http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Nuttery-Daisy-Fatball-Feeder/dp/B003TL0534/ref=sr_1_73?ie=UTF8&qid=1351367349&sr=8-73

2. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Metal-Fat-Ball-Bird-Food-Feeder-Ring-Holds-6-Fat-Balls-/230618397619?pt=UK_Home_Garden_Garden_Plants_Bird_Bath_Feeder_CV&var=&hash=item35b1ed7bb3
(the six holder one)

3. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/2-X-SUET-FEAST-BIRD-FEEDER-HANGING-METAL-CAGE-FAT-BALL-NEW-/230815797249?pt=UK_Home_Garden_Garden_Plants_Bird_Bath_Feeder_CV&hash=item35bdb19001

I'm leaning towards the second at the moment but I'm not 100%

None of the above. I would go for one of these

http://www.monsterpetsupplies.co.uk/p-15836-superpet-roll-the-hay-wheel.aspx

several companies sell them and they come off the stand.

That's not really the kind of thing I'm looking for, but thank you anyway

they roll around like a treat ball.

if you have a jollys near you,they sell something similar to number 2 but a bit better made,thats what ive got

cheryl'n'bruce'flo wrote:they roll around like a treat ball.

I want one that hangs up, and I want one that the hay can be accessed from all sides with

fall3n-ang3l wrote:if you have a jollys near you,they sell something similar to number 2 but a bit better made,thats what ive got

Ooo we do! Do you have a picture? Is it a small animal one or a bird one?

its a bird one,i have got a pic but its not a good one,let me try and find it

It's ok if it's not good, as long as I know what I'm looking for Can you remember how much it was?

i think it was between £6-7

I agree with Cheryl, the ones that she showed attatch to the side of the cage and they spin round so the bunny can get all the hay out. They also seem to leave less mess

havent used any of the others so couldnt say about them

We tied ones that move about and the buns just gave up. We also av the one in the pic and have it hooked on the run they both use it :-)

Does he not get on with just a hay rack? Maybe he could have a hay rack and then his treat ball that he has at the moment too.